Tuesday, January 29, 2008
el mundo pequeño
Here´s some lite fare to follow up my previous monster-sized post. A friend of mine from the Jewish community invited me to attend his sister´s wedding Saturday night, a huge event attended by upwards of 300 people. After a rousing hora, I found myself standing next to a woman that looked remarkably familiar. The odds of running into someone I know at a private event in Guatemala City are so slim that I figured this was just the result of my having left my glasses at home. When the woman returned my perplexed gaze, however, I confirmed that it was indeed ZU, my neighbor from the freshman dorms at Wesleyan! The bride was her cousin, and she was down for the week visiting family. What are the odds? We had the opportunity to talk and catch up, and of course take a here´s-proof-that-I-ran-into-someone-I-know-in-the-least-likely-of-places digital photo. One of the best rounds of Jewish Geography ever.
Monday, January 28, 2008
La mierda, el ventilador, y la resulta
Big changes afoot, and most likely for the best. Things at the total communication school have not been going well. Here is a synopsis of the issues:
1) To begin with, it must be made clear that ASORGUA and the COMITE are two entities that have precious little to do with one another. There is a very tangible tension between the two groups, and while it is a Gallaudet interest to collaborate with both, it is a conflict of interest to attempt to integrate them. I shall still be attending ASORGUA meetings on the weekend and hopefully doing needs assessment with them out of my own interest.
2) LP, the director of social work at the COMITE, authorized my internship but did not consult with ID or the school director before doing so. I was functioning under the assumption that he had discussed the role of an intern at the school with them, ony to find out that this is not the case. They have both been kind, but have also made it clear that there is not a structural niche for a student social worker 32 hours a week at the Centro de Comunicacion Total. I empathize with the fact that they were put in an uncomfortable position, but the situation has not been handled very well. Passive agression has ensued and I´ve been made to feel unwelcome on a number of fronts.
3) ID proposed a number of alternatives, which included working at the other Comite schools. She has asserted that there is no place for an intern at the school (I can´t tell you how great it would have been to have gotten this information just a bit earlier). As far as home visits are concerned, policy dictates that I cannot do them alone and ID has expressed concern about me accompanying her. Many of the neighborhoods she visits are astonishingly impoverished and people will not take kindly to a young outsider who looks like me entering their homes. In addition to the safety risks for myself, Imelda says I would be putting her at risk.
4) The kicker is the Guatemalan bureaucracy, about which I´ve gotten to learn a great deal. Note that I am not being sarcastic--it really has been valuable, however frustrating. Ultimately, the only person who has the authority to make any decisions is LP, who is terribly difficult to contact. Before even contacting the other nearby schools, we must go through him, and he was out of the office until this afternoon.
THANKFULLY, I have a phenominal supervisor MW who came in from Antigua today to advocate for and with me at the Comite office. We had an excellent meeting with LP and the new scoop is as follows:
A straight shoot up the PERIFERICO highway loop from Total Communication School is the Comite´s central office in Zone 1. We talked with LP and he was very kind and understanding. His recomendation was that I transfer to SECSA the educational-vocational program for Deaf adolescents. SECSA is located 2 short blocks from the Comite central office. We all walked over there and talked to HO, the director of the program. HO was so warm and welcoming, and has stated that there is room on her team for a masters student. She of course will be discussing things with the SECSA social worker tomorrow, to make sure she is comfortable with it. HO really made an excellent impression on MW and me, and seems more philosophically amenable to the idea of a partnership with Gallaudet.
Monday through Thursday and some Fridays, I will take one highway loop bus to the vicinity and walk 4 blocks to SECSA, which seems to be fairly safe. I will work with the SECSA ¨team¨which includes HO, the social worker, the psychologist and the instructors. The hours are 7am-3pm, which is more than enough to fulfill requirements. On Fridays, the students have vocational ¨practicas¨. This means that a group of teens and 1 teacher go to various businesses and the students work on a particular vocational skill like cooking or cutting hair. I can accompany ¨practica¨days when needed and I will also continue to attend ASORGUA meetings most weekends.
LP says that initially most of the swk practice will be team-based, but that there will likely be opportunity later in the internship to do one on one work with students. If everything is alright with the SECSA social worker, I will begin Weds morning. (Tomorrow I shall go to Total Communication School and inform them of the transfer).
It has come to light that the disconnect between Gallaudet and the Comite is much larger than any of us thought. This of course comes with the territory of pioneering a new internship. Please cross your fingers for me if you´re not using them to communicate. :)
1) To begin with, it must be made clear that ASORGUA and the COMITE are two entities that have precious little to do with one another. There is a very tangible tension between the two groups, and while it is a Gallaudet interest to collaborate with both, it is a conflict of interest to attempt to integrate them. I shall still be attending ASORGUA meetings on the weekend and hopefully doing needs assessment with them out of my own interest.
2) LP, the director of social work at the COMITE, authorized my internship but did not consult with ID or the school director before doing so. I was functioning under the assumption that he had discussed the role of an intern at the school with them, ony to find out that this is not the case. They have both been kind, but have also made it clear that there is not a structural niche for a student social worker 32 hours a week at the Centro de Comunicacion Total. I empathize with the fact that they were put in an uncomfortable position, but the situation has not been handled very well. Passive agression has ensued and I´ve been made to feel unwelcome on a number of fronts.
3) ID proposed a number of alternatives, which included working at the other Comite schools. She has asserted that there is no place for an intern at the school (I can´t tell you how great it would have been to have gotten this information just a bit earlier). As far as home visits are concerned, policy dictates that I cannot do them alone and ID has expressed concern about me accompanying her. Many of the neighborhoods she visits are astonishingly impoverished and people will not take kindly to a young outsider who looks like me entering their homes. In addition to the safety risks for myself, Imelda says I would be putting her at risk.
4) The kicker is the Guatemalan bureaucracy, about which I´ve gotten to learn a great deal. Note that I am not being sarcastic--it really has been valuable, however frustrating. Ultimately, the only person who has the authority to make any decisions is LP, who is terribly difficult to contact. Before even contacting the other nearby schools, we must go through him, and he was out of the office until this afternoon.
THANKFULLY, I have a phenominal supervisor MW who came in from Antigua today to advocate for and with me at the Comite office. We had an excellent meeting with LP and the new scoop is as follows:
A straight shoot up the PERIFERICO highway loop from Total Communication School is the Comite´s central office in Zone 1. We talked with LP and he was very kind and understanding. His recomendation was that I transfer to SECSA the educational-vocational program for Deaf adolescents. SECSA is located 2 short blocks from the Comite central office. We all walked over there and talked to HO, the director of the program. HO was so warm and welcoming, and has stated that there is room on her team for a masters student. She of course will be discussing things with the SECSA social worker tomorrow, to make sure she is comfortable with it. HO really made an excellent impression on MW and me, and seems more philosophically amenable to the idea of a partnership with Gallaudet.
Monday through Thursday and some Fridays, I will take one highway loop bus to the vicinity and walk 4 blocks to SECSA, which seems to be fairly safe. I will work with the SECSA ¨team¨which includes HO, the social worker, the psychologist and the instructors. The hours are 7am-3pm, which is more than enough to fulfill requirements. On Fridays, the students have vocational ¨practicas¨. This means that a group of teens and 1 teacher go to various businesses and the students work on a particular vocational skill like cooking or cutting hair. I can accompany ¨practica¨days when needed and I will also continue to attend ASORGUA meetings most weekends.
LP says that initially most of the swk practice will be team-based, but that there will likely be opportunity later in the internship to do one on one work with students. If everything is alright with the SECSA social worker, I will begin Weds morning. (Tomorrow I shall go to Total Communication School and inform them of the transfer).
It has come to light that the disconnect between Gallaudet and the Comite is much larger than any of us thought. This of course comes with the territory of pioneering a new internship. Please cross your fingers for me if you´re not using them to communicate. :)
Thursday, January 24, 2008
Dificultades
What I thought was just a slow start to my internship has actually proven to be a significant dilemma. It´s not a good time to disclose many details just yet, but as a result of bureaucratic miscommunications, I currently lack formal responsibilities, a role, and a stake in the school environment. I am still fulfilling hours until the snag gets resolved, but much of the work is clerical in nature. While it is not a personal issue, the school resents having been given an intern. Now is a fantastic time to find this out.
Tomorrow morning I will have the opportunity to work with some parents briefly, but structural changes to the practicum cannot be made until Monday at the earliest. It is upsetting to have lost purposefullness, but I understand that this sometimes comes with the territory of pioneer internships. The good thing is that things will definitely get resolved, as I have several potential options for lateral shifts. As a wise graduate assistant told me when I was having problems with internship planning last semester, I have the best kind of problem--one with a solution. In the mean time, I´ll just cross my fingers that the appropriate authorities make appropriate decisions to get this practicum back on track.
Tomorrow morning I will have the opportunity to work with some parents briefly, but structural changes to the practicum cannot be made until Monday at the earliest. It is upsetting to have lost purposefullness, but I understand that this sometimes comes with the territory of pioneer internships. The good thing is that things will definitely get resolved, as I have several potential options for lateral shifts. As a wise graduate assistant told me when I was having problems with internship planning last semester, I have the best kind of problem--one with a solution. In the mean time, I´ll just cross my fingers that the appropriate authorities make appropriate decisions to get this practicum back on track.
Monday, January 21, 2008
La Sordera
Today I had a conversation with the school social worker about common causes of hearing loss in this country. She had a lot to say about it, and I was happy to serve as a captive audience (because sometimes I get the feeling that she finds having an intern awkward and even burdensome...but that´s probably my paranoia talking).
The picture she painted was not very uplifting. She cited rubella and other infections as the most common medical causes, along with antibiotics given to treat bronchitis and (get this) ear infections. Complementary to medical problems were social problems. Most Guatemalans live in poverty, and at least half of the students at the school live in what is considered extreme poverty. They have no means to obtain medical care, and live in squalor.
Other families may have economic access to medical care but their faith instructs them to seek help only through faith, not through medicine. Most Guatemalans are Catholic or Evangelical, though there are a growing number of Jehovah´s Witnesses. And on the other side of the spectrum from faith, there is ignorance. ID explained disparagingly that most parents have no health education or parenting skills education, and often do not notice signs of hearing loss or diseases that lead to hearing loss in their children.
Perhaps ID has been exposed to this sadness too long, for she is really quite critical of parental behaviors. She noted their consumer mentality when it came to money management and finds some parents take her constant clothing and school supply donations for granted.
This discussion stood in stark contrast to IDs wonderfully warm conduct and positive regard for parents who have come to the school to see her. She is a truly gifted social worker and people-person with a lot of wisdom. I suppose every social worker gets jaded by experience eventually; the key is to try not to let it affect our work.
The picture she painted was not very uplifting. She cited rubella and other infections as the most common medical causes, along with antibiotics given to treat bronchitis and (get this) ear infections. Complementary to medical problems were social problems. Most Guatemalans live in poverty, and at least half of the students at the school live in what is considered extreme poverty. They have no means to obtain medical care, and live in squalor.
Other families may have economic access to medical care but their faith instructs them to seek help only through faith, not through medicine. Most Guatemalans are Catholic or Evangelical, though there are a growing number of Jehovah´s Witnesses. And on the other side of the spectrum from faith, there is ignorance. ID explained disparagingly that most parents have no health education or parenting skills education, and often do not notice signs of hearing loss or diseases that lead to hearing loss in their children.
Perhaps ID has been exposed to this sadness too long, for she is really quite critical of parental behaviors. She noted their consumer mentality when it came to money management and finds some parents take her constant clothing and school supply donations for granted.
This discussion stood in stark contrast to IDs wonderfully warm conduct and positive regard for parents who have come to the school to see her. She is a truly gifted social worker and people-person with a lot of wisdom. I suppose every social worker gets jaded by experience eventually; the key is to try not to let it affect our work.
Thursday, January 17, 2008
La Adopcion
CA and I planned to get together once more before she returned to the US, and chose the Camino Real as our rendezvous. As I sat on the couch in the lobby to wait for her (the very same couch on which the President of Aruba sat for his interview), I noted a strangely mixed group of people on the couches across from me. A man was translating for an old mayan woman who was articulating information about baby care and specifications. A teary-eyed couple with wisconsin accents listend intently. It was the finalization of an international adoption.
Minutes later, the mayan woman placed a baby girl in the American woman´s arms, and turned away. Her neice stood to comfort her as she cried silently. The air was thick and emotional. I couldn´t believe that I was this close to such a critical moment in both families´lives. I was obviously missing a lot of details, but was nonetheless overwhelmed by a contradictory mix of thoughts and feelings.
I am a strong proponent of building families through adoption, and international adoptions are very common. Guatemala, however, has been red flagged recently for problems and corruption with adoption, which tainted my observation of the scene. While everything seemed legally and socially legitimate, I couldn´t stop thinking about what the transaction meant to the Mayan family choosing not to parent the child.
The child´s change of family did not make me uncomfortable but the setting did. The couple adopting the child were guests at the finest hotel in the city, and did not speak Spanish. They were educated White people, who will likely make great parents, but how did the older woman feel relinquishing caretaking responsibilities for this baby in an environment that catered to wealthy foreigners? She will always remember the child as a mayan person, but will the child´s life reflect her heritage? On the other hand, would her quality of life have been sufficient had she remained with an aged relative without the means to care for her?
My anthropology, social work and personal wires all got crossed that afternoon. I want to restate that I´m not being critical of any party involved, but I feel unsettled nonetheless. I´ll chew on it for a little bit longer, with no intention of reaching a verdict.
Minutes later, the mayan woman placed a baby girl in the American woman´s arms, and turned away. Her neice stood to comfort her as she cried silently. The air was thick and emotional. I couldn´t believe that I was this close to such a critical moment in both families´lives. I was obviously missing a lot of details, but was nonetheless overwhelmed by a contradictory mix of thoughts and feelings.
I am a strong proponent of building families through adoption, and international adoptions are very common. Guatemala, however, has been red flagged recently for problems and corruption with adoption, which tainted my observation of the scene. While everything seemed legally and socially legitimate, I couldn´t stop thinking about what the transaction meant to the Mayan family choosing not to parent the child.
The child´s change of family did not make me uncomfortable but the setting did. The couple adopting the child were guests at the finest hotel in the city, and did not speak Spanish. They were educated White people, who will likely make great parents, but how did the older woman feel relinquishing caretaking responsibilities for this baby in an environment that catered to wealthy foreigners? She will always remember the child as a mayan person, but will the child´s life reflect her heritage? On the other hand, would her quality of life have been sufficient had she remained with an aged relative without the means to care for her?
My anthropology, social work and personal wires all got crossed that afternoon. I want to restate that I´m not being critical of any party involved, but I feel unsettled nonetheless. I´ll chew on it for a little bit longer, with no intention of reaching a verdict.
Trabajo Social
The school social worker, ID, has returned at last. She is a genial, upbeat middle aged woman who exerts a positive influence on the school environment. We rearranged her office to make room for 2 of us, and greeted and met with a slow trickle of parents with enrollment concerns. The major challenge is that the concept of a social work intern is not the same in Guate as it is in the US.
Everyone is glad to have me, but doesn´t have a clear idea of what I do. While they are eager to teach me things, I am trying hard to make it clear that I can also be a practitioner, assisting with work and shouldering responsibility. I´m sure this will come with time. In the mean time, my learning contract was a foreign object to ID. She smiled and reviewed my proposed goals and objectives, but I could tell by the uncomfortable nuance in her smile that it may take a few days to get roles sorted out.
On top of the intern role confusion, ID keeps suggesting that I only stay a month, then go to work at the deaf preschool on the other end of the eye-ear compound, and later to the oral deaf school on the other side of the city and the remote one in Quetzaltenango, Guatemala. She is very wise to acklowledge the importance of a well-rounded perspective, but it really is humorous how different our concepts are. I would like the opportunity to visit all of these places, but my first perogative is to iron out my current situation! Either way I´m learning tons and fullfilling direct practice hours, but I am concerned about my efficacy in serving the children and families. Oh, to be young, American and a guinea pig.
Everyone is glad to have me, but doesn´t have a clear idea of what I do. While they are eager to teach me things, I am trying hard to make it clear that I can also be a practitioner, assisting with work and shouldering responsibility. I´m sure this will come with time. In the mean time, my learning contract was a foreign object to ID. She smiled and reviewed my proposed goals and objectives, but I could tell by the uncomfortable nuance in her smile that it may take a few days to get roles sorted out.
On top of the intern role confusion, ID keeps suggesting that I only stay a month, then go to work at the deaf preschool on the other end of the eye-ear compound, and later to the oral deaf school on the other side of the city and the remote one in Quetzaltenango, Guatemala. She is very wise to acklowledge the importance of a well-rounded perspective, but it really is humorous how different our concepts are. I would like the opportunity to visit all of these places, but my first perogative is to iron out my current situation! Either way I´m learning tons and fullfilling direct practice hours, but I am concerned about my efficacy in serving the children and families. Oh, to be young, American and a guinea pig.
Karma Mala
I can´t believe it. Just days after I posted a complaint about the funky garage dog, she vanished. Yonela never came back, and J is sure she was stolen, or worse--met her fate on the peripheral highway ring. I can´t help but feel this is my fault. Her poor puppies! Luckily we´ve been teaching them to drink milk from a bowl, and I think they´ll be ok. That´ll show me to speak ill of another living creature.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
